Authoritarian Parenting Is Poison: Faith Beauchemin’s Thoughts

Authoritarian Parenting Is Poison: Faith Beauchemin’s Thoughts

The following piece was originally published by Faith Beauchemin on her blog Roses and Revolutionaries. It is reprinted with her permission. Also by Faith Beauchemin on HA: “The Importance Of Telling Your Own Story” and “Starship Captains and Dinosaurs.”

My parents wanted to be the best parents they could be.  It’s a pity that I barely even speak to them. It’s not really their fault, and I would forgive them immediately if they ever admitted their parenting had been wrong.  But they defend themselves and make excuses and believe that they were doing it all to the glory of God.  And if something is to God’s glory, of course it’s going to be good for every person involved.

But that’s not true at all. I suffer significant psychological and emotional distress to the point of being developmentally stunted in several ways because of my parents’ “god-centered” parenting techniques.

All the books and sermons available to my parents convinced them that their parenting techniques were correct.  Multiple authors and preachers basically bullied my parents and many others like them to completely dominate and break their childrens’ wills, because total obedience was God’s plan for children and if children could not obey their parents, how would they ever know how to obey God?  My parents were convinced that my eternal salvation rested on their success as parents.  If they did everything right, I would follow the Lord and be happy all my days.  Too bad I only started being truly happy after I left home and left the church.

In the interests of doing everything right, my parents chose to homeschool me and my siblings.  This, along with the very tiny church which was our only social interaction, meant my dad’s ideas and will completely dominated every aspect of my life growing up.  He passed it all off as God’s ideas and God’s will, but there was of course only one correct way to think of everything and that was my dad’s interpretation of Christianity.

As a young child, I was happy, imaginative, precocious, friendly, outgoing, intelligent, excited to explore new ideas, devouring books about dinosaurs, about history, and every story I could lay my hands on.  By the time I went to college, I was quiet, depressed, frightened of everything, unable to speak in public, socially awkward to a painful degree, and self-censoring as to what ideas I was willing to even entertain or think about. I channeled my intelligence into proving the few points that I believed were true, and disproving everything else.  My mind wasn’t just closed, it was completely locked down.  It took four long years at college to return me partially to the outgoing, intellectually curious, adventurous personality I had lost.

My parents broke my will.  They wanted to make me follow a prescribed course of life.  They had a particular bundle of beliefs that they wanted me to adopt and take with me forever.  Any flicker of self-interest, self-will, was seen as rebellion and immediately crushed.  Any personal desire contrary to their wishes was deemed sinful, and spanked out of me.  And, I cannot emphasize this enough, I never got away from my parents.  I was always in their home, always dominated by their influence, their thoughts and desires.  I had one channel of freedom, the books I checked out of the library.  But when every other part of my life was controlled so totally, I tended to closely self-censor on what books I would read or how I would interpret them.

The adversarial form of parenting, the one which sees the child’s self as automatically opposed to the parent’s authority, is unbelievably harmful to the parent/child relationship.  It took me a very long time to relate to my mom as a person rather than just an authority figure. I still can’t relate to my dad as a person, his whole being is consumed with his religion, and with trying to prioritize God in his life. He has obsessed for a long time over the fact that he’s the authority figure in the family and everyone needs to honor him, which come to think of it makes me a little worried about his mental health.  He hasn’t realized that it’s wrong to put your ideology before your children.  He doesn’t understand why we barely ever speak to him.

Even hearing about homeschooling families or reading materials written by people in the homeschooling or fundamentalist Christian movement can trigger flashbacks.  I am still working, every day, on reclaiming my self.  I wonder, sometimes, what life might have been like if I had been allowed to develop my own path instead of being forced to follow so closely my parents plan for my ideas and my life.  What might I have accomplished if I hadn’t wasted the first 19 years of my life focusing all my time and energy on matching up to this ideal Christian model held up by my parents.  Perfection was the goal and therefore it took all of my time and energy to try to reach that goal.

I have only just now, at age 23, begun with any kind of seriousness to figure out my place in the world.  Once I realized I had spent the vast majority of my life in a tiny insular principality, ruled by my father, which had very little to do with the rest of the world, I felt completely lost.  And who am I supposed to turn to to figure it out?  My parents? They’re the ones who screwed up my life this badly.

I have to rely on myself, the self that was squashed and harangued and abused almost out of existence.  I’ve survived, and I’ll go on to do something important and real and lasting in this world, but I will never know what could have happened in those years that are lost.

8 comments

  • Faith – thank you for sharing. I am so sorry that you lost 19 years of your life. I am so sorry that you had parents that did not meet your emotional or spiritual needs. I don’t know where it says this in the Bible but some where God promises to ” make up for the years the locust have eaten” It is something like that. I pray the the God of love and grace that created you will restore fully those years and you will find your giftings and talents and become all you were meant to be despite of years of spiritual and emotional abuse.

  • Headless Unicorn Guy

    “The adversarial form of parenting, the one which sees the child’s self as automatically opposed to the parent’s authority, is unbelievably harmful to the parent/child relationship.”

    Because that reduces parenting to Power Struggle and ONLY Power Struggle.

    And in Power Struggle, there are only two possible end states: My boot stamping on your face, or your boot stamping on mine. Nothing else.

  • I am so, so sorry that happened to you. Thank you for speaking up and for speaking against authoritarian, adversarial parenting.

  • Great comment, Headless Unicorn Guy.

  • Ugh… I often wish mine would apologize for their authoritarian parenting methods. But I can’t imagine that this will ever happen. That would require admitting that biblical child rearing methods are wrong, and they won’t have any part of that.

    Ah well, they are miserable now and are placing all their hopes in the after life. Their belief system has failed them over and over and over, and yet they won’t rescind any part of it. There are four of us kids, and the youngest two rarely ever talk to my parents.

    It’s very sad really.

  • Pingback: vygotsky and authoritarian parenting | very human problems

  • My parents are like this too. I wish to leave them, but I’m afraid they’ll file a police report, like they did when I went homeless trying to get away from them. I still want to get out and I’m 28, but the job market is really brutal, and I can’t get I high paying job with my MBA and get out of the state. I live in Illinois.

    • Admin Note:

      Hi alexis,

      I hear you about wanting to leave. It can be a hard and scary thing to try to leave a situation that is harmful.

      First, are you experiencing any physical abuse? (And you are not required to answer that.)

      Because you are over 18, so the police can’t make you go back. Also, it can be beneficial to call the police ahead of time and let them know you are leaving. This preempts your parents from making a call to the police that would place pressure on you.

      Also, the police can be utilized as a personal escort to help you leave their house.

      Please feel free to reach out to if you need to talk, or have more questions.
      (ha.edteam@gmail.com)

      Shade – Editorial Team

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s